This is an update on an earlier blog this month on the ex-Panamanian President, Manuel Noriega, who is now serving a ten-year sentence in France under money laundering charges. There was an issue over whether Noriega ought to be extradited to Panama, where he is wanted for other crimes still, or France. If sent to Panama, however, he would not have been able to be extradited again (if he lived out his sentence there) since the Panamanian constitution forbids the extradition of its citizens. Which presumes Noriega to still be a citizen of Panama. Previous international law cases, the historic Lotus case, for example, (in which Turkish courts were upheld the ability to try French nationals in Turkish jurisdictions), give credence to this sort of arbitrary due processing, where citizens tried abroad must uphold decisions that are made abroad.
Nonetheless, if Noriega had gone to Panama, it would certainly have raised questions and concerns domestically about the current government, led by President Martin Torrijos, who is a member of the same political party Noriega was, the Revolutionary Democratic Party. The current speaker of their National Assembly is also wanted for murder charges in the United States.
Thursday, September 13, 2007
Noriega and the Ambiguities of International Law
Submitted by
Acumensch
at
13.9.07
0
Comments
Tag Cloud: Imperialism
Wednesday, September 12, 2007
Was Ist Amerikaner Kultur?
Antwort: Dreck.
Submitted by
Acumensch
at
12.9.07
0
Comments
Tag Cloud: Situationism
The Soy Republic
A friend of mine studied the economics of soy production in Argentina this summer, which is one of the three largest soy producers next to Brazil and the US.
Since Monsanto genetically modified soy to be resistant to its Roundup weedkillers, the European Union placed a ban on GMed soy imports. And since this, the WTO ruled that this is disallowed under international trade law. This ruling seems fair to me, from a consumer-choice perspective, yet the simultaneous ruling which stated non-GM products may not advertise their being non-GM is unfair. Information ought to be as symmetrical as possible, and the WTO ruled against this.
It simply gives undeserved credibility to Roundup Ready GM soy, and prevents consumers from making intelligent choices. It is reasonable to believe, as the legal jargon goes, that since there are studied and unstudied health affects of GM soy, many consumers would prefer non-GM soy. More than half of rats exposed to GM soy died prematurely compared to rats that weren't exposed. The fact that GM soy is exposed to much more Roundup weedkillers than non-GM soy should be a red flag. This is due to the fact that GM soy's DNA contains bacterial genes that allow the soy plant to survive heavy exposure to Monsanto's "Roundup" brand herbicide. Some 85 percent of the soy gown in the United States is Roundup Ready. Soy is present in the majority of processed foods sold in the United States, so most Americans eat Roundup Ready soy in some form every day.
Soy is the food of the future. Meat will be phased out if we are to live with sustainability on this planet. It is interesting, then, that the soy we eat is so infected with dangerous elements. GM soy is also grown carelessly--since there is little or no variation in GM products, the risk of an entire crop failure is much higher. Adverse weather conditions may affect a particular genetic makeup, and with little variation, the entire crop fails. Weeds all over the world have grown resistant to the now heavy use of Roundup weedkillers, and Monsanto is struggling to deter this. In Argentina, two weeds have grown resistant. In the US, an even larger number of weeds have grown resistant, due to our long practice of spraying herbicides.
Greenpeace and other organizations have documented the systematic environmental degradation due to GM soy production in Argentina. Run-off from Roundup ends up in major rives, polluting everything, and eventually reaching the ocean. Soy farm expansion, due to a favorable export price, increases deforestation. This in turn has led to floods, not to mention a loss of natural capital and habitat. In Brazil, of course, part of the destruction of the Amazon is due to expanding soy and cattle production.
What should be done?
The first step seems obvious--give consumers to freedom to choose their soy products, through the WTO. Free trade also means free information. Producers and distributors ought to be allowed to put the information they find relevant on their product. Since GM soy is often fed to cattle and other animals, cattle producers who don't use GM soy also ought to be able to advertise this.
Submitted by
Acumensch
at
12.9.07
2
Comments
Tag Cloud: Food crisis
The Entire Economic Situation For Dependency Theorists
After reading a few articles by Theotonio Dos Santos on the new form of dependence in post-colonial international relations, why should we think that at any point in the argument that something unfair has happened? Dos Santos is a Marxist who takes the entire economic situation, including the apparent exploitation of poor countries by rich countries through loans, and claims that inequalities in the system mean that something has gone terribly wrong with capitalism itself. For example, he cites the use of loans given by rich countries to poor countries as a way to exploit the surplus labor, by means of collecting their profits through interest payments. It is true that these loans have not helped development on a realistic level. Loans have in fact helped development, but not as quickly as the lenders predicted. Yet to engage in contracts with lenders is a choice made by the underdeveloped country. Many writers on development have said that there is hardly a legal system which deals with property rights in slowly developing countries. Hernando de Soto, for example, says that without such a legal structure, the assumptions of capitalist development are simply not valid in developing countries. His conclusion: all the more reason to have a functioning system of property rights, then!
Still, loan arrangements are based on the risk involved in the situation. Why should the lenders be to blame here? Or why should they be forced to ignore risk? Nothing Dos Santos cites is anything that can legitimately be complained about from a free market perspective without violating the right of free choice to engage in such agreements. From the point of view of national capitalist development in underdeveloped countries, the kinds of development policies Dos Santos recommends, like import-substitution and nationalization of industries, simply makes its industries less competitive with foreign industry and thus giving them no access to the benefits of international trade, such as cheaper commodities on international markets. How are capitalist industries supposed to obtain capital in the first place if they are given unfavorable trade conditions with foreigners? They are, of course, supposed to take on all industries themselves. Dependency theory thus leads to complete isolationism.
In the Marxian tradition, this is simply the effect of economic imperialism on underdeveloped nations. It is interesting that Dos Santos pits rich countries against poor countries, when in fact, there is a wide ranch of disparity within countries that doesn't seem to be addressed. A rich person in any country can arrange a loan with a poor person in any country. If the poor person finds the conditions of the loan unacceptable, it is their choice whether to accept it or not. Competition among lenders helps to make loans more favorable. And unless contracts are breached, there is nothing lenders are doing wrong. From an international social welfare point of view, I find Dos Santos arguments completely unacceptable.
Submitted by
Acumensch
at
12.9.07
0
Comments
Tag Cloud: Imperialism
Tuesday, September 11, 2007
The "Mad World" of Post 9/11
The events of 9/11 could perhaps be called the first world historic event in a strict sense: the impact, the explosion, the slow collapse--a gruesome reality that took place in front of a global audience. The misery in war-torn Afghanistan meanwhile are reminiscent of images of something like a 30-Years' War, yet this time with the impossibility of a Westphalian Peace. It has been six years today, as we mark the anniversary of the of the attack and the invasion. This year the war has become personal, however. My brother deployed to Iraq in the last few weeks. His Myspace profile is generally the only way we keep in touch. His page is currently playing "Mad World," a song by Gary Jules which is unsettling, since it deals with issues like being an outcast, being unloved or unappreciated by everyone in your life, especially throughout primary education. It begins to look like a suicide note, for someone who is entering the most dangerous city on earth, Baghdad. From my perspective, there is almost nothing for me to say about this. We were both raised as foster youth before we moved out of our homes and joined the real world. We lived together in solidarity of this fact. Is he therefore entering Iraq willingly? And is fighting a war the way for him to demonstrate to everyone else that he is someone to be appreciated?
These issues are decidedly less philosophical, and sound more like pop-psychology. It seems almost trite to spell these words out. It would disgust me if I ever sounded like the politically-disengaged family members of soldiers who cannot reflect on the situation with critical resolve and intelligence. In general when someone has a family member entering Afghanistan or Iraq, they become suddenly much more sympathetic to the goals of the militarists and the War on Terror mission. Our family members have since ceased to debate with me about the politics surrounding the war. It has become a personal issue that disregards politics altogether. We talk about our brother as if he were just like any other relative living in a far-off place, maybe in Idaho or Saskatchewan. But in fact, he's engaged in an immoral war of aggression that has been legitimized by our government. How does one deal with the issue, mainly, of maintaining this position, without giving credence to meaningless slogans like "Support the Troops," which end up simply lending support to the war and undermining the entire position.
Submitted by
Acumensch
at
11.9.07
0
Comments
Tag Cloud: Deconstructing war on terror
An 'Inner' Morality of the Law?
Most political demonstrations that actually try to do something are illegal. And the usual reply to direct action is strict legalism, which doesn't address the arguments that protesters make. It's tiring when legalism itself is so often cited as if 'morality' were bound to it. Morality and law are two separate things. But to push the thesis even further, there is no morality. This is something I'm comfortable with saying. There is no morality. There is only moral sentiment. And these sentiments are not universal. You cannot speak of duties to any of these things--'morality' or 'law'--insofar as they do not exist or there is nothing binding about them. So my Kantianism doesn't go very far. Still, if you had a duty it would be to preserve the nebulousness of 'morality' foremost and 'law' second.
Some have suggested, however, that there is an inner morality to the law itself. I tend to agree with this argument that Lon Fuller puts forth, but only to a certain extent. On this account, a legal system itself has to meet certain conditions which then make it even functional, and only when it's a functioning legal system can we talk about whether there is morality to its external practices and whether we are bound to it. Fuller argues for a natural law theory about this legal system. But I disagree: there isn't any kind of morality built into the system. There is nothing inside it or coincidental with it. There are only relativistic moral sentiments of those legislating, and the historicism about the history of lawmaking attests to this. But there is an interesting point to make here which doesn't leave us completely in the dark. Meeting these conditions certainly makes a legal system useful and functional for legislating. And that is the first objective--isn't it--to make legal systems functional? At this point, nobody is worried about whether we're doing what is "morally right": because it is preferable to have no legal system at all, then to have one in which, for example, cases are decided by the King ex post facto at the end of each year. We would not know which rules to follow before breaking them! So our first question is simply a question of functionality and structure. We can then ask, for what purpose should the legal system have a purpose? And that, I would say, is to facilitate a society where no one person's rights are violated for the sake of anyone or anything else.
Law basically has three functions then. Maintaining property rights, human rights, and enforcing contracts. I don't think we are truly bound to any system which demands more of us than this. Such a society ensures that no individual rights are violated. But in fact, we can pressure this further and ask whether we are even by nature bound to a system which demands these basic rules? It is possible to live outside the system entirely. Individualist Anarchists like Murray Rothbard would certainly argue for it. Yet I suppose it depends on what your sentiments are. But here is something firm: having a structure to assert the trustworthiness of a contract is certainly useful, and so is having the right to property and protection from invading marauders. So in this way, the minimal state has an attraction to it, and those on the outside would want membership. It isn't coercive in any way.
But back to the political demonstrations, which is really what I want to make a point about. For those of us who believe we live under a tyrannical regime by the very nature and structure of our legal system, have we any recourse but to violently oppose our government? We do not like this policy of war-making in our name. Our elected officials have failed us. There is corporate lobbying in the White House. These are all things for which I oppose my government. The petitions for which we have signed have not been considered thoughtfully, and it isn't simply 'representation' which is lacking. Have I, then, an obligation to follow the rules of my government obediently? To the extent that following these rules are useful, yes. But its external laws (that is, everything legislated) never seemed morally binding to me in the first place. To the extent that change is more important than temporary comfort, the obligation seems null.
JFK said, "Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable," and I believe this is certainly true. Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable. Is it true then that peaceful revolution is impossible? Consider what has happened in the last six years since 9/11. No one outside the Congress and the special war cabinets decided whether there was indeed a justified causus belli for the invasion of Iraq. The petitions of citizenry have no effect, and individuals' rights are being violated. Will peacefully signing more of the petitions change anything government is doing to violate these rights? No, this is impossible at this point. General Petraeus has said we ought to spend ten more years in Iraq, and this is unacceptable if you share the sentiment. And so, affirming JFK's point, and realizing that the encouragement for 'peaceful change' is the osing argument, then indeed a violent revolution is inevitable at this point.
Submitted by
Acumensch
at
11.9.07
0
Comments
Tag Cloud: Critical legal
